3 Inclusive Paradigm
Inclusive Paradigm affirms the salvific presence of God in non-Christian religions while still maintaining that Christ is the definitive and authoritative revelation of God.
Karl Rahner’s Inclusivist Approach
Rahner maintains that salvation comes only through faith in God through Christ and again argues the salvific presence of God in non- Christian religions. To hold the two principles in balance he argues that:
When we have to keep in mind both principles together, namely the necessity of Christian faith and the universal salvific will of God’s love and omnipotence, we can only reconcile them by saying that somehow all men must be capable of being members of the Church; and this capacity must not be understood merely in the sense of an abstract and purely logical possibility, but as a real and historically concrete one.1
Rahner gives four thesis to explain his position:
1.Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion, intended for all men, which cannot recognise any other religion beside itself as of equal right. Rahner adds a statement to this thesis by saying, the fact that Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion must be balanced by the difficulties involved in discerning ‘when the existentially real demand is made by the absolute religion in its historically tangible form.’2
2.The universal salvific will of God revealed in Christ can be experienced by non-Christian religions. He argues that God must somehow offer grace to all those who have never properly encountered the Gospel. The grace of God must be made available through and not despite the non-Christian’s religion
3.A non-Christian may have already accepted God’s grace in the depths of his or her heart by doing good. If a non- Christian has responded positively to God’s grace, through selfless love for another, then even though it is not known objectively, that person has accepted the God that is historically and definitively revealed in Christ. God’s salvation cannot be divorced from Christ; hence the term ‘anonymous Christian’ is more appropriate than ‘anonymous theist’.
4.The church cannot be seen as an elite community of those who are saved as opposed to the mass of unredeemed non-Christian humanity. The church is a tangible sign of the faith, hope and love made visible, present and irreversible in Christ. The Inclusive approach affirms that the only possible normative truth basis for Christians is Christ, while accommodating the salvific experience in non-Christian religions. The inclusivist challenges the pluralist removal of Christ and his church from the centre of the universe of faiths and those exclusivist who sever the relationship between Christ and other faiths.
3.3 The Lordship of Jesus Christ and Religious Pluralism
The Lordship of Christ is one of the central affirmation of the New Testament, the manner in which it was expressed was developed in the West where religious pluralism was not a big issue. Those of us Africans whose history, tradition, culture, and social relationship are different from those in the West do not find it easy to bear this burden of this heritage. This means that the involvement of African Christians in pluralist communities should be taken serious. The divine-human encounter in Jesus Christ is the basis for this confession.
The obvious mark of a Christian is the confession that Jesus Christ is Lord (2Cor. 4:5; Rom. 10:9; Col. 2:6 etc). It signifies a new relationship of the believer to Jesus Christ, of commitment and loyalty, of surrendering oneself to God and to the one Lord, Jesus Christ. It is an affirmation that by virtue of his death and resurrection Jesus Christ has been exalted above all lords.
There are three main points in the New Testament that can help in understanding the Lordship of Jesus Christ in the context of religious pluralism. The first is the connection between the confession of Christ’s Lordship and faith in his resurrection. The second is the relation between the exaltation of Jesus Christ as Lord and his humility, his suffering, his emptying himself, his servant hood. The third is the unique combination of the fatherhood of God with the Lordship of Jesus Christ.3 This leads us to a major question as to how Christians can witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ as they live with neighbours of other faiths. Christians should witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ by proclaiming the salvation of Jesus Christ and actively involve in the struggle for justice. Christians should also share with neighbours of other faith that in Jesus Christ the Ultimate has become intimate with humanity, “that nowhere else is the victory over suffering and death manifested so decisively as in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.”4
4. African Christianity and Afrikania Movement
Christianity is universal; the particularity of African Christianity should provide a contribution to the universal church. This contribution will defuse the Afrikania claim that what Africa needs is African Traditional Religion as an alternate to Christianity. The following statements of Komfo Damuah confirm the challenge the movement poses to the Church. His fundamental problem with Christianity in Africa lies in what he said:
Christianity is generally viewed by Africans as not indigenously African, but rather a white man’s religion, because as in other ‘pagan’ areas of the world, Christian missionaries often opposed or denigrated traditional local customs and institutions: veneration of ancestors, traditional tribal ceremonies and authority systems, and polygamy…5
Damuah proposed a solution to the problem of what he called the great dilemma facing Africans today’ by calling for a ‘new synthesis’ a reconstruction of the traditional religion which he considers as the divine purpose for Africa and for the world. He mentions in the Afrikania handbook what the movement wants to achieve.
It is not a new religion. It is a traditional African Religion ‘come alive’, reformed and updated. Afrikania is here not to destroy but to fulfil the dream of a new Africa. It is Africa’s religion of today’s generation, but it is open to all, irrespective of race, creed, colour or ideological orientation.6
Perhaps the most fundamental challenge Afrikania poses to Christianity in Africa is the question of cultural identity: the question of Ghanaian Christian identity. Bediako has raised the following questions that need further research. Have churches in Africa especially the mainline churches, adequately indigenised the Christian gospel by making full use of the potential elements of faith rooted in our traditional religions?
Christianity and Islam: With particular reference to Shariah Law
Shariah or Islamic Law which has become a a big challenge to the world especially in some countries in Africa especially in Nigeria. The system of law that governed a flourishing Islamic society for centuries has become a backward practice of endorsing corporal punishment. The traditional practice of Islamic law has been overshadowed by extreme interpretations.
Shariah is founded on three sources: the Quran, traditions and guidance of the scholars in authority.
Extreme Shariah: Extremism in Islam constitutes a total disregard for the principles of inclusiveness inherent in the faith.
1.The Punishment for Theft: The punishment for theft is the amputation of the hand.
2.The Punishment for Adultery: The punishment for adultery is death by stoning.
3.Death Penalty: Many countries choose not to endorse the death penalty, and even among those that do, its application is tempered by rules.
Extremist Hegemony: Extremist leaders attempting to create a puritanical overnight, disregard the practical aspects inherent in Islamic law, and ignore the fundamentals of human nature and societal conditioning. They put themselves in a position where they must try and overpower man’s resistance by brute force in order to institute their system of governance. Extreme leaders exert tremendous effort to prevent Muslims from living under a democratic system. They aim to prevent the spread of democracy because it will cancel their hegemony.
In the year 2000 eleven Northern states in Nigeria re-Islamised their legal system. The penal codes have adopted most of the provisions and added new provisions on the Quranic offences like: Theft, Unlawful Sexual Intercourse, Robbery, Defamation, Drinking Alcohol. The fixed punishment for unlawful sexual intercourse are stoning to death for persons who are currently married or have ever contracted a valid marriage. For those who have never contracted a marriage, the punishment is one hundred lashes and in addition, banishment for men. Theft is to be punished by amputation of the right hand. Robbery is punished by death if a life has been taken, by death by crucifixion if both lives and property have been taken, by amputation of both the right hand and the left foot if only property has been taken, and by banishment if there was only a “hold up” without further aggravation. Drinking alcohol are both punishable with eighty lashes.
Faith, Tradition and Modernity
God has made us and we are in relationship with God whether we recognise it or not. The Bible speaks of humankind as God’s image, as being unique and communal, and as having an identity which is derived and not autonomous. The chief end of human existence is and will be always to serve God and enjoy him forever in both our personal and communal lives. There is an immerse confusion when we try to interrelate faith, tradition and modernity. Our priorities creates problems when God is left out of the game. The image of God is marred and tarnished. Of ourselves we are powerless, alienated fragmented, fearful. What makes a Christian anthropology good news, is the message that Jesus Christ, the incarnate word of God, came to share our humanity and to redeem it through the cross. Our wholeness depends on the quality of relationship with God.
Christian Faith and Tradition
The critical debate between Christian faith an d tradition pose serious questions regarding the role of tradition in Christianity and between tradition and modernity. During the Colonial period the traditional leaders took the approach of ‘Sankofa’ and the missionaries took the approach of ‘to wamanmmere gu’ do away with or throw away your cultural practices. According to the missionaries cultural values have no place in Christianity. The traditional leaders especially the Afrikania movement assert that Christianity is a foreign religion and therefore Africa must reject it and make African Traditional Religion her god given religion. The Afrikania Movement emphasises that: Christianity and Islam do not seem to satisfy adequate Africa’s quest for identity and self-determination. He posits that a reconstructed Traditional African Religion may be considered as a likely answer to Africa’s search for freedom and self-determination. ATR can exist in its own right on equal terms with other religions within an ecumenical framework.
The Afrikania Movement has raised pertinent questions regarding African Christianity, especially the question of identity. The movement is asking whether Christian Africa has adequately appropriated the faith that she espouses. Have Christian churches adequately indigenised the Christian gospel by making use of religious values in their culture? The movement rejects Christianity and advocates ATR as an alternative religion to Christianity. Rejecting Christianity is not the solution to African’s quest for authentic African religion. The challenge confronting the Church in Africa is appropriating positive ideas of faith from our tradition, which are compatible with the Christian faith and the scriptures.
Modernity, Information Technology and Christian Faith
The dominating technology today is the information technology which creates our images of the world. How do we as African Church relate to this global phenomenon when the Church in Africa is concerned about African spirituality. What sort of church do we need in an information society? The big challenge is a church on the move, always relevant for today’s world. If the church cannot communicate in the language and culture of this present generation, it is tragically out of touch, not only with the world today but also with the God of today. The church finds itself in a crisis of communication as we move into an information society. This modern culture is characterised by a belief in cause and effect – an indefinite cycle of production of consumption, self-interest with capital system. The message of most churches is based on cycle of production of consumption, self-interest – prosperity message.
Four interrelated reasons why we need to pay attention to information technology
1.It is a heartland technology which will influence all aspects of our life in a much more comprehensive way than the technology of the industrial society.
2.It raises questions about power and information gulfs
3.The speed of technological change is accelerating. As a result the technology, including bio and gene technology out runs the political decision processes
4.The consequences of the development of IT are far reaching and global.. The entire society may be transformed into a global village.
Technology as an Idol of Modern Culture
There is at least little doubt that the technology has become the universal language of modern culture. If you cannot read and talk that language you have lost even before you start. And the language is primarily that of IT. Wherever you go in the world, you see the footprints of our technology and hear the sound of its electronics.
The problem is that the worldview of technology turns everything upside down; it transforms the means into goals, and the good becomes pragmatic that which makes things happen. Technology creates our image of the world and defines society and worldview. What is dangerous here is the power we give to technology and the way we combine it with our self interest for where this happens technology will assume a religious character. The mistake is not in technology the problem began when we developed technology within a culture that no longer had room for a living God and His purpose for life. The culture in which the technology has been developed has gone astray and technology becomes an idol for this reason.
Where technology gains a religious character it becomes a threat to religion.
1.The technological worldview will divert our world’s interest, motivation, satisfaction, and energy away from a religious center. Example: empty churches in Europe
2.The technological worldview takes the power out of our religious vocabulary. Religious symbols images and rituals become meaningless.
3.The technological surroundings encourage a religiosity which has little or no interest in organised religion.
The church in Africa is caught in a middle of two strong ideologies
1.African Spirituality: Dealing with the African past – spirit world, ancestors, fetishism, witchcraft, worship of rivers, trees, stones etc.
2.Modern Technology – Major shift to the future with little or no relevance to our past.
The Church in Africa can not let go our past and discard our future. We need a good balance.
Extreme Spirituality – Has its problems. Especially when there is much emphasis on the devil. We see any move in a negative way creating fear and confusion. No attempt to venture to the future. We limit the power of God and give priority to the devil and his evil activities.
Extreme modernism – results in secularization.
Saturday, 14 March 2009
The Pluralist Paradigm
2 The Pluralist Paradigm
(a)John Hick’s Pluralist Approach
John Hicks adopts the pluralist view. According to John Hicks, God is the centre and that all religions serve and revolve around Him. Hicks theological argument is based on the affirmation of the universal salvific will of God. ‘We say as Christians that God is the God of universal love, that he is the Creator and Father of all mankind, that he wills the ultimate good and salvation of all men’.
Hick asks whether such a God could have ‘ordained that men must be saved in such a way that only a small minority can in fact receive this salvation? His answer is ‘No’. It is precisely the doctrine of a God of universal love that dictates Hick’s answer.
The theological argument of the universal salvific will of God is a fundamental principle of the pluralist approach. Hick has been criticized by many theologians for abandoning the central Christian truth of the incarnation of Jesus Christ as the only to salvation and subverting the distinctiveness of Christianity.
The trust of Hick’s argument is twofold. First, ‘New Testament scholarship has shown how fragmentary and ambiguous are the data available to us’, so much so that he has called Jesus ‘the largely unknown man of Nazareth’. Hence, there is not enough historical evidence on which to base a claim for the divinity of Jesus and such evidence as there is, shows that the historical Jesus did not make for himself the claims that the Church was later to make for him.
According to Hick, the attitude of Christians to other religions need not be characterised by mistrust, desire to convert or superiority, but a will to learn and grow together towards the truth.
(b)Osofo Komfo Damuah’s Pluralist Approach
Komfo Damuah began his Christian ministry as Roman Catholic priest. He furthered his education in United States. Twenty five years after his ordination as a Roman Catholic priest he left the Catholic Church and founded the Afrikania Mission and took the name of Osofo Okomfo (fetish priest) Kwabena Damuah. While in the Roman Catholic ministry he did his PhD at Howard University and wrote on the topic ‘The changing perspective of Wasa Amanfi traditional religion in contemporary Africa’.
The focus for Damuah’s study was his own people group in the Wasa Amanfi, which he came to consider as a statement of divine self-disclosure through the traditional religion.Damuah also linked his study to the modern Africa search for independence from the Colonial rule. He proposed five key statements for Africa independence:
The profundity of Traditional African Religion and how it pervades every aspect of traditional Africa;
1.How this characteristic is ingrained even today in the twentieth century non-Westernised African
2.How Christianity and Islam do not seem to satisfy adequately Africa’s quest for identity and self-determination
1How a reconstructed Traditional African Religion may be considered as a likely answer to Africa’s search for freedom and self-determination
(3)That Traditional African Religion can exist in its own right on equal terms with other religions within an ecumenical framework.
The most important part of his thesis was the last chapter ‘The Search for a New Synthesis’. He states what he considered to be the problem:
The conflict over the meaning of being African runs through all African life today – religion, the arts and popular culture and education – so that it is in these areas that many of the crucial struggles over Africa’s future in the world are being decided. When it comes to religious values, contemporary Africa is the battleground of four contending forces:
Traditional Religion, Christianity, Islam and religiously indifferent materialism. The traditional religions seem to be everywhere in decline, … There is no attempt to capitalise on any specific traditional religion. Nowhere in Africa is there anything parallel to the organised pressures for a return to Hindu theocracy found in India, State Shinto in Japan.
Having isolated traditional religion as the most crucial index of the critical state of African societies, Damuah then sought to show how both Christianity and Islam do not seem to satisfy adequately Africa’s search for identity and self-determination. Damuah’s new synthesis is a reconstruction of the traditional religion, which he affirmed as being within the divine purpose for Africa and for the world. He states that:
The time has come when the African intellectual must take a new look and help resuscitate Traditional African Religion so that she can take her rightful place in the struggle for liberation and self-determination. The fact that she has been able to survive despite the encroachment of Christianity and Islam is an indication that there is something in the tradition, which God wants, preserved.
The Afrikania mission that Damuah established seeks to be a ‘universal’ religion from Africa and from African tradition, reaching to the wider world with universal vocation. It is traditional African religion with the aim of fulfilling the dream of the new Africa. ‘It is Africa’s religion of today’s generation, but it is open to all, irrespective of race, creed, colour or ideological orientation’.
The most fundamental challenge of Damuah and Afrikania to Christianity in Africa is the issue of identity, the problem of the identity of Christian Africa. Damuah sums up the challenge Afrikania poses to Christianity in Africa in his own words:
Mental bondage is mental violence
Religious bondage is invisible violence
Cultural bondage is cultural suicide
The time for liberation (is) now.
3.2.3 Inclusive Paradigm
Inclusive Paradigm affirms the salvific presence of God in non-Christian religions while still maintaining that Christ is the definitive and authoritative revelation of God.
Karl Rahner’s Inclusivist Approach
Rahner maintains that salvation comes only through faith in God through Christ and again argues the salvific presence of God in non- Christian religions. To hold the two principles in balance he argues that:
When we have to keep in mind both principles together, namely the necessity of Christian faith and the universal salvific will of God’s love and omnipotence, we can only reconcile them by saying that somehow all men must be capable of being members of the Church; and this capacity must not be understood merely in the sense of an abstract and purely logical possibility, but as a real and historically concrete one.1
Rahner gives four thesis to explain his position:
1.Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion, intended for all men, which cannot recognise any other religion beside itself as of equal right. Rahner adds a statement to this thesis by saying, the fact that Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion must be balanced by the difficulties involved in discerning ‘when the existentially real demand is made by the absolute religion in its historically tangible form.’2
2.The universal salvific will of God revealed in Christ can be experienced by non-Christian religions. He argues that God must somehow offer grace to all those who have never properly encountered the Gospel. The grace of God must be made available through and not despite the non-Christian’s religion
3.A non-Christian may have already accepted God’s grace in the depths of his or her heart by doing good. If a non- Christian has responded positively to God’s grace, through selfless love for another, then even though it is not known objectively, that person has accepted the God that is historically and definitively revealed in Christ. God’s salvation cannot be divorced from Christ; hence the term ‘anonymous Christian’ is more appropriate than ‘anonymous theist’.
4.The church cannot be seen as an elite community of those who are saved as opposed to the mass of unredeemed non-Christian humanity. The church is a tangible sign of the faith, hope and love made visible, present and irreversible in Christ. The Inclusive approach affirms that the only possible normative truth basis for Christians is Christ, while accommodating the salvific experience in non-Christian religions. The inclusivist challenges the pluralist removal of Christ and his church from the centre of the universe of faiths and those exclusivist who sever the relationship between Christ and other faiths.
3.3 The Lordship of Jesus Christ and Religious Pluralism
The Lordship of Christ is one of the central affirmation of the New Testament, the manner in which it was expressed was developed in the West where religious pluralism was not a big issue. Those of us Africans whose history, tradition, culture, and social relationship are different from those in the West do not find it easy to bear this burden of this heritage. This means that the involvement of African Christians in pluralist communities should be taken serious. The divine-human encounter in Jesus Christ is the basis for this confession.
The obvious mark of a Christian is the confession that Jesus Christ is Lord (2Cor. 4:5; Rom. 10:9; Col. 2:6 etc). It signifies a new relationship of the believer to Jesus Christ, of commitment and loyalty, of surrendering oneself to God and to the one Lord, Jesus Christ. It is an affirmation that by virtue of his death and resurrection Jesus Christ has been exalted above all lords.
There are three main points in the New Testament that can help in understanding the Lordship of Jesus Christ in the context of religious pluralism. The first is the connection between the confession of Christ’s Lordship and faith in his resurrection. The second is the relation between the exaltation of Jesus Christ as Lord and his humility, his suffering, his emptying himself, his servant hood. The third is the unique combination of the fatherhood of God with the Lordship of Jesus Christ.3 This leads us to a major question as to how Christians can witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ as they live with neighbours of other faiths. Christians should witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ by proclaiming the salvation of Jesus Christ and actively involve in the struggle for justice. Christians should also share with neighbours of other faith that in Jesus Christ the Ultimate has become intimate with humanity, “that nowhere else is the victory over suffering and death manifested so decisively as in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.”4
4. African Christianity and Afrikania Movement
Christianity is universal; the particularity of African Christianity should provide a contribution to the universal church. This contribution will defuse the Afrikania claim that what Africa needs is African Traditional Religion as an alternate to Christianity. The following statements of Komfo Damuah confirm the challenge the movement poses to the Church. His fundamental problem with Christianity in Africa lies in what he said:
Christianity is generally viewed by Africans as not indigenously African, but rather a white man’s religion, because as in other ‘pagan’ areas of the world, Christian missionaries often opposed or denigrated traditional local customs and institutions: veneration of ancestors, traditional tribal ceremonies and authority systems, and polygamy…5
Damuah proposed a solution to the problem of what he called the great dilemma facing Africans today’ by calling for a ‘new synthesis’ a reconstruction of the traditional religion which he considers as the divine purpose for Africa and for the world. He mentions in the Afrikania handbook what the movement wants to achieve.
It is not a new religion. It is a traditional African Religion ‘come alive’, reformed and updated. Afrikania is here not to destroy but to fulfil the dream of a new Africa. It is Africa’s religion of today’s generation, but it is open to all, irrespective of race, creed, colour or ideological orientation.6
Perhaps the most fundamental challenge Afrikania poses to Christianity in Africa is the question of cultural identity: the question of Ghanaian Christian identity. Bediako has raised the following questions that need further research. Have churches in Africa especially the mainline churches, adequately indigenous the Christian gospel by making full use of the potential elements of faith rooted in our traditional religions?
Christianity and Islam: With particular reference to Shariah Law
Shariah or Islamic Law which has become a a big challenge to the world especially in some countries in Africa especially in Nigeria. The system of law that governed a flourishing Islamic society for centuries has become a backward practice of endorsing corporal punishment. The traditional practice of Islamic law has been overshadowed by extreme interpretations.
Shariah is founded on three sources: the Quran, traditions and guidance of the scholars in authority.
Extreme Shariah: Extremism in Islam constitutes a total disregard for the principles of inclusiveness inherent in the faith.
1.The Punishment for Theft: The punishment for theft is the amputation of the hand.
2.The Punishment for Adultery: The punishment for adultery is death by stoning.
3.Death Penalty: Many countries choose not to endorse the death penalty, and even among those that do, its application is tempered by rules.
Extremist Hegemony: Extremist leaders attempting to create a puritanical overnight, disregard the practical aspects inherent in Islamic law, and ignore the fundamentals of human nature and societal conditioning. They put themselves in a position where they must try and overpower man’s resistance by brute force in order to institute their system of governance. Extreme leaders exert tremendous effort to prevent Muslims from living under a democratic system. They aim to prevent the spread of democracy because it will cancel their hegemony.
In the year 2000 eleven Northern states in Nigeria re-Islamised their legal system. The penal codes have adopted most of the provisions and added new provisions on the Quranic offences like: Theft, Unlawful Sexual Intercourse, Robbery, Defamation, Drinking Alcohol. The fixed punishment for unlawful sexual intercourse are stoning to death for persons who are currently married or have ever contracted a valid marriage. For those who have never contracted a marriage, the punishment is one hundred lashes and in addition, banishment for men. Theft is to be punished by amputation of the right hand. Robbery is punished by death if a life has been taken, by death by crucifixion if both lives and property have been taken, by amputation of both the right hand and the left foot if only property has been taken, and by banishment if there was only a “hold up” without further aggravation. Drinking alcohol are both punishable with eighty lashes.
Faith, Tradition and Modernity
God has made us and we are in relationship with God whether we recognise it or not. The Bible speaks of humankind as God’s image, as being unique and communal, and as having an identity which is derived and not autonomous. The chief end of human existence is and will be always to serve God and enjoy him forever in both our personal and communal lives. There is an immerse confusion when we try to interrelate faith, tradition and modernity. Our priorities creates problems when God is left out of the game. The image of God is marred and tarnished. Of ourselves we are powerless, alienated fragmented, fearful. What makes a Christian anthropology good news, is the message that Jesus Christ, the incarnate word of God, came to share our humanity and to redeem it through the cross. Our wholeness depends on the quality of relationship with God.
(a)John Hick’s Pluralist Approach
John Hicks adopts the pluralist view. According to John Hicks, God is the centre and that all religions serve and revolve around Him. Hicks theological argument is based on the affirmation of the universal salvific will of God. ‘We say as Christians that God is the God of universal love, that he is the Creator and Father of all mankind, that he wills the ultimate good and salvation of all men’.
Hick asks whether such a God could have ‘ordained that men must be saved in such a way that only a small minority can in fact receive this salvation? His answer is ‘No’. It is precisely the doctrine of a God of universal love that dictates Hick’s answer.
The theological argument of the universal salvific will of God is a fundamental principle of the pluralist approach. Hick has been criticized by many theologians for abandoning the central Christian truth of the incarnation of Jesus Christ as the only to salvation and subverting the distinctiveness of Christianity.
The trust of Hick’s argument is twofold. First, ‘New Testament scholarship has shown how fragmentary and ambiguous are the data available to us’, so much so that he has called Jesus ‘the largely unknown man of Nazareth’. Hence, there is not enough historical evidence on which to base a claim for the divinity of Jesus and such evidence as there is, shows that the historical Jesus did not make for himself the claims that the Church was later to make for him.
According to Hick, the attitude of Christians to other religions need not be characterised by mistrust, desire to convert or superiority, but a will to learn and grow together towards the truth.
(b)Osofo Komfo Damuah’s Pluralist Approach
Komfo Damuah began his Christian ministry as Roman Catholic priest. He furthered his education in United States. Twenty five years after his ordination as a Roman Catholic priest he left the Catholic Church and founded the Afrikania Mission and took the name of Osofo Okomfo (fetish priest) Kwabena Damuah. While in the Roman Catholic ministry he did his PhD at Howard University and wrote on the topic ‘The changing perspective of Wasa Amanfi traditional religion in contemporary Africa’.
The focus for Damuah’s study was his own people group in the Wasa Amanfi, which he came to consider as a statement of divine self-disclosure through the traditional religion.Damuah also linked his study to the modern Africa search for independence from the Colonial rule. He proposed five key statements for Africa independence:
The profundity of Traditional African Religion and how it pervades every aspect of traditional Africa;
1.How this characteristic is ingrained even today in the twentieth century non-Westernised African
2.How Christianity and Islam do not seem to satisfy adequately Africa’s quest for identity and self-determination
1How a reconstructed Traditional African Religion may be considered as a likely answer to Africa’s search for freedom and self-determination
(3)That Traditional African Religion can exist in its own right on equal terms with other religions within an ecumenical framework.
The most important part of his thesis was the last chapter ‘The Search for a New Synthesis’. He states what he considered to be the problem:
The conflict over the meaning of being African runs through all African life today – religion, the arts and popular culture and education – so that it is in these areas that many of the crucial struggles over Africa’s future in the world are being decided. When it comes to religious values, contemporary Africa is the battleground of four contending forces:
Traditional Religion, Christianity, Islam and religiously indifferent materialism. The traditional religions seem to be everywhere in decline, … There is no attempt to capitalise on any specific traditional religion. Nowhere in Africa is there anything parallel to the organised pressures for a return to Hindu theocracy found in India, State Shinto in Japan.
Having isolated traditional religion as the most crucial index of the critical state of African societies, Damuah then sought to show how both Christianity and Islam do not seem to satisfy adequately Africa’s search for identity and self-determination. Damuah’s new synthesis is a reconstruction of the traditional religion, which he affirmed as being within the divine purpose for Africa and for the world. He states that:
The time has come when the African intellectual must take a new look and help resuscitate Traditional African Religion so that she can take her rightful place in the struggle for liberation and self-determination. The fact that she has been able to survive despite the encroachment of Christianity and Islam is an indication that there is something in the tradition, which God wants, preserved.
The Afrikania mission that Damuah established seeks to be a ‘universal’ religion from Africa and from African tradition, reaching to the wider world with universal vocation. It is traditional African religion with the aim of fulfilling the dream of the new Africa. ‘It is Africa’s religion of today’s generation, but it is open to all, irrespective of race, creed, colour or ideological orientation’.
The most fundamental challenge of Damuah and Afrikania to Christianity in Africa is the issue of identity, the problem of the identity of Christian Africa. Damuah sums up the challenge Afrikania poses to Christianity in Africa in his own words:
Mental bondage is mental violence
Religious bondage is invisible violence
Cultural bondage is cultural suicide
The time for liberation (is) now.
3.2.3 Inclusive Paradigm
Inclusive Paradigm affirms the salvific presence of God in non-Christian religions while still maintaining that Christ is the definitive and authoritative revelation of God.
Karl Rahner’s Inclusivist Approach
Rahner maintains that salvation comes only through faith in God through Christ and again argues the salvific presence of God in non- Christian religions. To hold the two principles in balance he argues that:
When we have to keep in mind both principles together, namely the necessity of Christian faith and the universal salvific will of God’s love and omnipotence, we can only reconcile them by saying that somehow all men must be capable of being members of the Church; and this capacity must not be understood merely in the sense of an abstract and purely logical possibility, but as a real and historically concrete one.1
Rahner gives four thesis to explain his position:
1.Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion, intended for all men, which cannot recognise any other religion beside itself as of equal right. Rahner adds a statement to this thesis by saying, the fact that Christianity understands itself as the absolute religion must be balanced by the difficulties involved in discerning ‘when the existentially real demand is made by the absolute religion in its historically tangible form.’2
2.The universal salvific will of God revealed in Christ can be experienced by non-Christian religions. He argues that God must somehow offer grace to all those who have never properly encountered the Gospel. The grace of God must be made available through and not despite the non-Christian’s religion
3.A non-Christian may have already accepted God’s grace in the depths of his or her heart by doing good. If a non- Christian has responded positively to God’s grace, through selfless love for another, then even though it is not known objectively, that person has accepted the God that is historically and definitively revealed in Christ. God’s salvation cannot be divorced from Christ; hence the term ‘anonymous Christian’ is more appropriate than ‘anonymous theist’.
4.The church cannot be seen as an elite community of those who are saved as opposed to the mass of unredeemed non-Christian humanity. The church is a tangible sign of the faith, hope and love made visible, present and irreversible in Christ. The Inclusive approach affirms that the only possible normative truth basis for Christians is Christ, while accommodating the salvific experience in non-Christian religions. The inclusivist challenges the pluralist removal of Christ and his church from the centre of the universe of faiths and those exclusivist who sever the relationship between Christ and other faiths.
3.3 The Lordship of Jesus Christ and Religious Pluralism
The Lordship of Christ is one of the central affirmation of the New Testament, the manner in which it was expressed was developed in the West where religious pluralism was not a big issue. Those of us Africans whose history, tradition, culture, and social relationship are different from those in the West do not find it easy to bear this burden of this heritage. This means that the involvement of African Christians in pluralist communities should be taken serious. The divine-human encounter in Jesus Christ is the basis for this confession.
The obvious mark of a Christian is the confession that Jesus Christ is Lord (2Cor. 4:5; Rom. 10:9; Col. 2:6 etc). It signifies a new relationship of the believer to Jesus Christ, of commitment and loyalty, of surrendering oneself to God and to the one Lord, Jesus Christ. It is an affirmation that by virtue of his death and resurrection Jesus Christ has been exalted above all lords.
There are three main points in the New Testament that can help in understanding the Lordship of Jesus Christ in the context of religious pluralism. The first is the connection between the confession of Christ’s Lordship and faith in his resurrection. The second is the relation between the exaltation of Jesus Christ as Lord and his humility, his suffering, his emptying himself, his servant hood. The third is the unique combination of the fatherhood of God with the Lordship of Jesus Christ.3 This leads us to a major question as to how Christians can witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ as they live with neighbours of other faiths. Christians should witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ by proclaiming the salvation of Jesus Christ and actively involve in the struggle for justice. Christians should also share with neighbours of other faith that in Jesus Christ the Ultimate has become intimate with humanity, “that nowhere else is the victory over suffering and death manifested so decisively as in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.”4
4. African Christianity and Afrikania Movement
Christianity is universal; the particularity of African Christianity should provide a contribution to the universal church. This contribution will defuse the Afrikania claim that what Africa needs is African Traditional Religion as an alternate to Christianity. The following statements of Komfo Damuah confirm the challenge the movement poses to the Church. His fundamental problem with Christianity in Africa lies in what he said:
Christianity is generally viewed by Africans as not indigenously African, but rather a white man’s religion, because as in other ‘pagan’ areas of the world, Christian missionaries often opposed or denigrated traditional local customs and institutions: veneration of ancestors, traditional tribal ceremonies and authority systems, and polygamy…5
Damuah proposed a solution to the problem of what he called the great dilemma facing Africans today’ by calling for a ‘new synthesis’ a reconstruction of the traditional religion which he considers as the divine purpose for Africa and for the world. He mentions in the Afrikania handbook what the movement wants to achieve.
It is not a new religion. It is a traditional African Religion ‘come alive’, reformed and updated. Afrikania is here not to destroy but to fulfil the dream of a new Africa. It is Africa’s religion of today’s generation, but it is open to all, irrespective of race, creed, colour or ideological orientation.6
Perhaps the most fundamental challenge Afrikania poses to Christianity in Africa is the question of cultural identity: the question of Ghanaian Christian identity. Bediako has raised the following questions that need further research. Have churches in Africa especially the mainline churches, adequately indigenous the Christian gospel by making full use of the potential elements of faith rooted in our traditional religions?
Christianity and Islam: With particular reference to Shariah Law
Shariah or Islamic Law which has become a a big challenge to the world especially in some countries in Africa especially in Nigeria. The system of law that governed a flourishing Islamic society for centuries has become a backward practice of endorsing corporal punishment. The traditional practice of Islamic law has been overshadowed by extreme interpretations.
Shariah is founded on three sources: the Quran, traditions and guidance of the scholars in authority.
Extreme Shariah: Extremism in Islam constitutes a total disregard for the principles of inclusiveness inherent in the faith.
1.The Punishment for Theft: The punishment for theft is the amputation of the hand.
2.The Punishment for Adultery: The punishment for adultery is death by stoning.
3.Death Penalty: Many countries choose not to endorse the death penalty, and even among those that do, its application is tempered by rules.
Extremist Hegemony: Extremist leaders attempting to create a puritanical overnight, disregard the practical aspects inherent in Islamic law, and ignore the fundamentals of human nature and societal conditioning. They put themselves in a position where they must try and overpower man’s resistance by brute force in order to institute their system of governance. Extreme leaders exert tremendous effort to prevent Muslims from living under a democratic system. They aim to prevent the spread of democracy because it will cancel their hegemony.
In the year 2000 eleven Northern states in Nigeria re-Islamised their legal system. The penal codes have adopted most of the provisions and added new provisions on the Quranic offences like: Theft, Unlawful Sexual Intercourse, Robbery, Defamation, Drinking Alcohol. The fixed punishment for unlawful sexual intercourse are stoning to death for persons who are currently married or have ever contracted a valid marriage. For those who have never contracted a marriage, the punishment is one hundred lashes and in addition, banishment for men. Theft is to be punished by amputation of the right hand. Robbery is punished by death if a life has been taken, by death by crucifixion if both lives and property have been taken, by amputation of both the right hand and the left foot if only property has been taken, and by banishment if there was only a “hold up” without further aggravation. Drinking alcohol are both punishable with eighty lashes.
Faith, Tradition and Modernity
God has made us and we are in relationship with God whether we recognise it or not. The Bible speaks of humankind as God’s image, as being unique and communal, and as having an identity which is derived and not autonomous. The chief end of human existence is and will be always to serve God and enjoy him forever in both our personal and communal lives. There is an immerse confusion when we try to interrelate faith, tradition and modernity. Our priorities creates problems when God is left out of the game. The image of God is marred and tarnished. Of ourselves we are powerless, alienated fragmented, fearful. What makes a Christian anthropology good news, is the message that Jesus Christ, the incarnate word of God, came to share our humanity and to redeem it through the cross. Our wholeness depends on the quality of relationship with God.
Approaches to Religious Pluralism in Africa
Approaches to Religious Pluralism in Africa
There are three different approaches to religious pluralism: Exclusivist, Pluralist and Inclusive paradigms
1. Exclusivist Paradigm.
They maintain that all have sinned including other religions and that Christ offers the only valid way to salvation.
(a)Hendrik Kraemer’s Exclusivist Approach
Kraemer, an advocate of exclusivism, says that, “God has revealed the Way and the Life and the Truth in Jesus Christ and wills this to be known through the world. That salvation is found only through the grace of God revealed in Christ”.
(b)Byang Kato’s Exclusivist Approach
Byang Kato’s starting point is that the Bible is God’s Word in its entirely, without errors. It is the final authority in all that affirms. He considered ‘inerrancy’ so important that, he would not accept infallibility as an adequate description of the trustworthiness of the Bible.
In Kato’s view the whole exercise of exploring other religious values and ideas and appropriating them for a possible contribution to African Christian thought is a denial of ‘the sufficiency of the scriptures as the sole authority for faith and practice. He is of the view that the church in Africa is heading towards universalism. He defines universalism as ‘the belief that all men will eventually be saved whether they believe in Christ now or not’. He gives reasons why universalism poses a threat to African Christianity.
First, he mentions modern mission agencies. Some American Baptist missionaries have a universalistic view and those who oppose such a view ask why these missionaries should be allowed to serve on the mission field.
Secondly, the new political awareness in Africa promotes universalism. There is a search for political solidarity and the goal of African Government is to unify all ethnic groups into one nation. ‘Universalism would be an excellent tool for uniting people of different faiths.
Thirdly, Africa is searching for personal identity and this makes the continent prone to syncretism.
Fourthly, the reawakening of African traditional religious thought of some African Christian scholars promotes universalism. Kato agrees to a partial and superficial method of adaptation of African Christianity. His view point is that Christians should be willing to adapt African culture to Christianity provided it does not conflict with scripture.
Kato’s understanding of the relationship between other religions and the Christian faith is that they constitute two distinct and discontinuous entities. Kato’s viewpoint on the centrality of the Bible as the starting point for doing theology in Africa is his important contribution to modern African Christianity.
There are three different approaches to religious pluralism: Exclusivist, Pluralist and Inclusive paradigms
1. Exclusivist Paradigm.
They maintain that all have sinned including other religions and that Christ offers the only valid way to salvation.
(a)Hendrik Kraemer’s Exclusivist Approach
Kraemer, an advocate of exclusivism, says that, “God has revealed the Way and the Life and the Truth in Jesus Christ and wills this to be known through the world. That salvation is found only through the grace of God revealed in Christ”.
(b)Byang Kato’s Exclusivist Approach
Byang Kato’s starting point is that the Bible is God’s Word in its entirely, without errors. It is the final authority in all that affirms. He considered ‘inerrancy’ so important that, he would not accept infallibility as an adequate description of the trustworthiness of the Bible.
In Kato’s view the whole exercise of exploring other religious values and ideas and appropriating them for a possible contribution to African Christian thought is a denial of ‘the sufficiency of the scriptures as the sole authority for faith and practice. He is of the view that the church in Africa is heading towards universalism. He defines universalism as ‘the belief that all men will eventually be saved whether they believe in Christ now or not’. He gives reasons why universalism poses a threat to African Christianity.
First, he mentions modern mission agencies. Some American Baptist missionaries have a universalistic view and those who oppose such a view ask why these missionaries should be allowed to serve on the mission field.
Secondly, the new political awareness in Africa promotes universalism. There is a search for political solidarity and the goal of African Government is to unify all ethnic groups into one nation. ‘Universalism would be an excellent tool for uniting people of different faiths.
Thirdly, Africa is searching for personal identity and this makes the continent prone to syncretism.
Fourthly, the reawakening of African traditional religious thought of some African Christian scholars promotes universalism. Kato agrees to a partial and superficial method of adaptation of African Christianity. His view point is that Christians should be willing to adapt African culture to Christianity provided it does not conflict with scripture.
Kato’s understanding of the relationship between other religions and the Christian faith is that they constitute two distinct and discontinuous entities. Kato’s viewpoint on the centrality of the Bible as the starting point for doing theology in Africa is his important contribution to modern African Christianity.
The Challenge from the Non-Christian Religions
The Challenge from the Non-Christian Religions
It is often said that our age is one of increasing materialism, which has resulted in the widening the gap between the rich and the poor. And this has also resulted in a revolt against all forms of religion. Sometimes these are associated with political movements and politicians use these occasions for their own ends. A combination of politics and religion produces a compound of immense dynamic energy. This has been the case again and again in the history of the church. A typical example is the Reformation period. In Africa we find many of the non-Christian religions, in alliance with political movements, asserting their claims with fresh vigor.
They bring a challenge that is both positive and negative. On the one hand they deny the claim of Christianity to be the final or even the highest – type of religion; on the other hand they invite Christians to join with them in resisting the advance of materialism unfair trade, civil wars and ethnic tensions, HIV Aids2
Other Religions refusal to admit the superiority of Christianity
The main tradition of Christendom has always claimed that the Christian religion is not only superior to all others, but is final and absolute truth for all time. This claim has, indeed never been admitted by the adherents of other faiths. In 1862, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, founder of Aligarh Muslim University, published a Mahomedan commentary on the Bible at Ghazipur. He commented that ‘We Mohammedans hold that Jesus Christ is honorable in this world, and in the world to come…The Apostles of Christ were inspired men…The Injeel (Gospels) are all true and sacred records, proceeding primarily from God.’3 In 1922 Syed Ahmer Ali maintained that in every department of life the teaching and example of Muhammad is superior to that of Jesus Christ. Sir Md. Iqbal has affirmed that while European (Christian) ideas are today hindering the progress of humanity, Islam alone points the true way of advance.4
It is often said that our age is one of increasing materialism, which has resulted in the widening the gap between the rich and the poor. And this has also resulted in a revolt against all forms of religion. Sometimes these are associated with political movements and politicians use these occasions for their own ends. A combination of politics and religion produces a compound of immense dynamic energy. This has been the case again and again in the history of the church. A typical example is the Reformation period. In Africa we find many of the non-Christian religions, in alliance with political movements, asserting their claims with fresh vigor.
They bring a challenge that is both positive and negative. On the one hand they deny the claim of Christianity to be the final or even the highest – type of religion; on the other hand they invite Christians to join with them in resisting the advance of materialism unfair trade, civil wars and ethnic tensions, HIV Aids2
Other Religions refusal to admit the superiority of Christianity
The main tradition of Christendom has always claimed that the Christian religion is not only superior to all others, but is final and absolute truth for all time. This claim has, indeed never been admitted by the adherents of other faiths. In 1862, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, founder of Aligarh Muslim University, published a Mahomedan commentary on the Bible at Ghazipur. He commented that ‘We Mohammedans hold that Jesus Christ is honorable in this world, and in the world to come…The Apostles of Christ were inspired men…The Injeel (Gospels) are all true and sacred records, proceeding primarily from God.’3 In 1922 Syed Ahmer Ali maintained that in every department of life the teaching and example of Muhammad is superior to that of Jesus Christ. Sir Md. Iqbal has affirmed that while European (Christian) ideas are today hindering the progress of humanity, Islam alone points the true way of advance.4
African Christianity and Religious Pluralism
Christianity exists in a world of religious pluralism, so the Christian attitude to other religions is a pressing issue on today’s pastoral agenda. In Africa one of the major challenges facing the continent as a clash of civilisation is religious pluralism. The three major religions in Africa are: Christianity, Islam, and African Traditional Religion.
The major question confronting the African Christian is the Christian attitude to other religions. How confess the Lordship of Jesus Christ as we live and work together with neighbours of other faiths? Why have the Islam and ATR posed a great challenge to Christianity? The major religions in Africa, Islam and ATR, deny the claim of Christianity to be the final or even the highest type of religion. The Christian faith has always claimed that Christian religion is not only superior to all others, but is final and absolute truth for all time. This claim has indeed never been admitted by these major religions. In 1922, Syed Ameer Ali, in his book ‘The Spirit of Islam’, maintained that in every department of life, teaching and example of Mohammed is superior to that of Jesus Christ.1 S.A.W. Bukhari of the Jamalia Arabic College, Madras, writes; ‘revelation is not the monopoly of one section of the people to the exclusion of another. Allah is not the God of the Jews or Christians or Muslims only’.2
In Africa, Islam and African Traditional Religion are reacting to the Global transformation that is taking place. The reaction is a mixture of anger, incomprehension and violent hatred. The notion of a clash of civilization in which Muslims and African Traditional Religion are seen as the main opponents. This has raised many questions like:
1.Does the Quran preach violence?
2.Do Muslims hate Jews and Christians?
3.Why is the message of peace and compassion of the world’s religion lost in the din of anger and hatred?
The major question confronting the African Christian is the Christian attitude to other religions. How confess the Lordship of Jesus Christ as we live and work together with neighbours of other faiths? Why have the Islam and ATR posed a great challenge to Christianity? The major religions in Africa, Islam and ATR, deny the claim of Christianity to be the final or even the highest type of religion. The Christian faith has always claimed that Christian religion is not only superior to all others, but is final and absolute truth for all time. This claim has indeed never been admitted by these major religions. In 1922, Syed Ameer Ali, in his book ‘The Spirit of Islam’, maintained that in every department of life, teaching and example of Mohammed is superior to that of Jesus Christ.1 S.A.W. Bukhari of the Jamalia Arabic College, Madras, writes; ‘revelation is not the monopoly of one section of the people to the exclusion of another. Allah is not the God of the Jews or Christians or Muslims only’.2
In Africa, Islam and African Traditional Religion are reacting to the Global transformation that is taking place. The reaction is a mixture of anger, incomprehension and violent hatred. The notion of a clash of civilization in which Muslims and African Traditional Religion are seen as the main opponents. This has raised many questions like:
1.Does the Quran preach violence?
2.Do Muslims hate Jews and Christians?
3.Why is the message of peace and compassion of the world’s religion lost in the din of anger and hatred?
2. African Christianity and the concept of Time and History
2. African Christianity and the concept of Time and History
Another significant feature in dealing with African Christianity in Post-modern world is African conceptualisation of time. It is a renewal of history, a fresh appreciation of past events revisited in the present and projected into the future. It runs ahead towards the new, towards the new, towards the future, even in repetitions. As Paul Tillich explains, “the time of creation is not determined by the physical time in which it is produced but by the creative context, which is used and transformed by it”1 Mbiti’s understanding of the African view of time was first expressed in his doctoral thesis, in which he attempted to examine New Testament eschatology from an African cultural perspective. He did a study of the Akamba (his own tribe in Kenya) and came to the conclusion that Akamba’s view of time can be conceived of as two-dimensional ‘with a long past and a dynamic present’, the future is virtually non-existent.2 He later generalised this to be true of the thinking of all of Africa.
The linear concept of time in Western thought with an indefinite past, present and infinite future is practically foreign to African thinking. The future is virtually absent because event which lies in it have not taken place, they have not been realised and cannot, therefore constitute time… What is taking place now no doubt unfolds the future, but once an event has taken place, it is no longer in the future but in the present and what is past.3
According to Mbiti this understanding of time under girds the African understanding of himself or herself, the community and his or her universe. He asserts, “when Africans reckon time, it is for a concrete and specific purpose, in connection with events but not just for the sake of mathematics”4 The modern Africa is discovering the future dimension of time due to Christian teaching, Western education and modern technology. Mbiti’s concept of time may be identified with the Akamba tribe but it is an over-generalisation to state that this concept of time is true for all of Africa. Nor is it the ‘key’ for understanding “the African worldview”. The diversity of Africa with over a thousand languages shows that the concept of time among the Akamba tribe may be different from that of others. The Asante (a major ethnic group in Ghana) concept of time is different from that of the Akamba people, because the past is revisited in the present and projected into the future. It is more than cyclical or linear; it has the notion of a ‘spiral’. Mbiti’s understanding of time cannot be accepted as definitive for all Africa, but it does give valuable insights to a concept of time among Akamba that is very different from that of the Asante. What is different between the Akamba and Asante is that while in Akamba future is virtually non-existent in Asante the past is projected into the future. This means that any religion that does not give the Asante a linkage to his past as a key to future orientation is likely to be misunderstood or ignored.
Another significant feature in dealing with African Christianity in Post-modern world is African conceptualisation of time. It is a renewal of history, a fresh appreciation of past events revisited in the present and projected into the future. It runs ahead towards the new, towards the new, towards the future, even in repetitions. As Paul Tillich explains, “the time of creation is not determined by the physical time in which it is produced but by the creative context, which is used and transformed by it”1 Mbiti’s understanding of the African view of time was first expressed in his doctoral thesis, in which he attempted to examine New Testament eschatology from an African cultural perspective. He did a study of the Akamba (his own tribe in Kenya) and came to the conclusion that Akamba’s view of time can be conceived of as two-dimensional ‘with a long past and a dynamic present’, the future is virtually non-existent.2 He later generalised this to be true of the thinking of all of Africa.
The linear concept of time in Western thought with an indefinite past, present and infinite future is practically foreign to African thinking. The future is virtually absent because event which lies in it have not taken place, they have not been realised and cannot, therefore constitute time… What is taking place now no doubt unfolds the future, but once an event has taken place, it is no longer in the future but in the present and what is past.3
According to Mbiti this understanding of time under girds the African understanding of himself or herself, the community and his or her universe. He asserts, “when Africans reckon time, it is for a concrete and specific purpose, in connection with events but not just for the sake of mathematics”4 The modern Africa is discovering the future dimension of time due to Christian teaching, Western education and modern technology. Mbiti’s concept of time may be identified with the Akamba tribe but it is an over-generalisation to state that this concept of time is true for all of Africa. Nor is it the ‘key’ for understanding “the African worldview”. The diversity of Africa with over a thousand languages shows that the concept of time among the Akamba tribe may be different from that of others. The Asante (a major ethnic group in Ghana) concept of time is different from that of the Akamba people, because the past is revisited in the present and projected into the future. It is more than cyclical or linear; it has the notion of a ‘spiral’. Mbiti’s understanding of time cannot be accepted as definitive for all Africa, but it does give valuable insights to a concept of time among Akamba that is very different from that of the Asante. What is different between the Akamba and Asante is that while in Akamba future is virtually non-existent in Asante the past is projected into the future. This means that any religion that does not give the Asante a linkage to his past as a key to future orientation is likely to be misunderstood or ignored.
Christianity and African Traditional Culture
1. Christianity and African Traditional Culture
The critical debate between the missionaries and traditional leaders posed serious questions regarding the role of culture in Christianity. The traditional leaders took the approach of “cultural revivalism”, that is, reviving the culture in its totality. The missionaries took the approach of “cultural anti-revivalism” that is, doing away with or throwing away the cultural practices.1
The ‘cultural revivalists’ including the Afrikania movement argues firstly that the commitment to the cultural heritage of the people will serve as the basis of the search for cultural identity and cultural pride and unite them as a society. Secondly, reviving one’s culture would also create authentic values for the future, ‘their perception of reality, their understanding of themselves, and their shared apprehension and interpretation of societal experience’2 Thirdly, there is the assumption that recovering and developing one’s cultural past becomes the basis of making a contribution to global civilisation. Fourthly, they argue that cultural revivalism will lead to mental freedom from a colonial mentality. According to Okomfo Damuah, ‘mental bondage is mental violence, religious bondage is invisible violence and cultural bondage is cultural suicide’.3 Colonial rule makes the colonised people intellectually servile to the ideas and values of the Colonial Government. Fifthly, they argue that the reason why some societies in Ghana are not developing is due to the fact that they tend to use foreign ideas to which they have no ideological attachment. Okomfo Damuah mentioned that, “the main trend is to discover our own authentic native values and grow from those roots rather than trying to be an extension or offshoot of other traditions”4 Lastly, they argue that reviving the cultural past will contribute to national integration and nation building.
The argument of the ‘cultural revivalists’ referring to the missionaries is that if Christianity is going to grow in Africa and also ‘catch-up’ with modernity then Africa must abandon a great part of their cultural practices that is archaic and primitive.5 The attitude of the church towards all traditional beliefs suggests that Christians should abandon any form of contact with spirit-powers and spirit –ancestors, all use of magic and fear of witchcraft.6 Any attempt to revive the cultural practices would be irrelevant to the goals and concerns of the African Christian.
The firm stand of these two groups has led to tensions, confusions, controversies and inconsistencies, and this is due to the failure to distinguish between what may be regarded as positive and negative elements in the culture. It is this failure that led the revivalist group to regard the entire culture to be positive, good, and perfect, while the anti-revivalist group saw everything in the culture negative, worthless and good for nothing.
The grounds for evaluating where a tradition should be accepted, refined or abandoned may be several. Some may see a tradition to be dysfunctional and hampers the progress of a society, “others may see it as discordant with the ethos of a new set of cultural values that a new generation is bent on establishing”7others may see it as morally unacceptable to the society.
In my view, neither the revivalists nor the anti-revivalist are entirely correct in their argument and criticism. They are both mistaken and unjustifiable views. The anti-revivalist (I am referring to the extreme group) position implies that though culture is the embodiment of people’s way of life nothing useful can be derived from the ideas, values and practices of their culture. They see no reason why the past must be revived. Gospel and culture are for them ‘polar’ concepts that cannot be integrated.8 In my view, to argue that a great part of people’s culture be rejected is unacceptable. In fact a total rejection of one’s cultural past would be absurd. The revival of some cultural values is very legitimate and relevant, and this is what this study is seeking to do. But not every aspect of a cultural heritage ought to be revived. Thus it will be impossible for me to support the position of the revivalist, if that position were to advocate the revival of the whole corpus of the culture. For the revivalist also argues that for development to take place the whole culture must be revived. I disagree with this position, because some cultural elements hinder progress. The revivalist who does not show any awareness of the negative features of the culture that impede progress, is misguided and his view will be counterproductive.
My position is neither cultural revivalism nor cultural anti-revivalism but appropriating the positive elements in African culture. By appropriation I mean, critically examining ideas and values embedded in African culture and giving them a theological meaning. Some of the values would have to be retrieved, refined, improved, and re-evaluated. There are values that can be regarded as so fundamental to the existence of the African culture that they transcend every generation. Appropriating these elements and giving them theological meaning will suggest that something worthwhile can be developed from the African cultural past.
The critical debate between the missionaries and traditional leaders posed serious questions regarding the role of culture in Christianity. The traditional leaders took the approach of “cultural revivalism”, that is, reviving the culture in its totality. The missionaries took the approach of “cultural anti-revivalism” that is, doing away with or throwing away the cultural practices.1
The ‘cultural revivalists’ including the Afrikania movement argues firstly that the commitment to the cultural heritage of the people will serve as the basis of the search for cultural identity and cultural pride and unite them as a society. Secondly, reviving one’s culture would also create authentic values for the future, ‘their perception of reality, their understanding of themselves, and their shared apprehension and interpretation of societal experience’2 Thirdly, there is the assumption that recovering and developing one’s cultural past becomes the basis of making a contribution to global civilisation. Fourthly, they argue that cultural revivalism will lead to mental freedom from a colonial mentality. According to Okomfo Damuah, ‘mental bondage is mental violence, religious bondage is invisible violence and cultural bondage is cultural suicide’.3 Colonial rule makes the colonised people intellectually servile to the ideas and values of the Colonial Government. Fifthly, they argue that the reason why some societies in Ghana are not developing is due to the fact that they tend to use foreign ideas to which they have no ideological attachment. Okomfo Damuah mentioned that, “the main trend is to discover our own authentic native values and grow from those roots rather than trying to be an extension or offshoot of other traditions”4 Lastly, they argue that reviving the cultural past will contribute to national integration and nation building.
The argument of the ‘cultural revivalists’ referring to the missionaries is that if Christianity is going to grow in Africa and also ‘catch-up’ with modernity then Africa must abandon a great part of their cultural practices that is archaic and primitive.5 The attitude of the church towards all traditional beliefs suggests that Christians should abandon any form of contact with spirit-powers and spirit –ancestors, all use of magic and fear of witchcraft.6 Any attempt to revive the cultural practices would be irrelevant to the goals and concerns of the African Christian.
The firm stand of these two groups has led to tensions, confusions, controversies and inconsistencies, and this is due to the failure to distinguish between what may be regarded as positive and negative elements in the culture. It is this failure that led the revivalist group to regard the entire culture to be positive, good, and perfect, while the anti-revivalist group saw everything in the culture negative, worthless and good for nothing.
The grounds for evaluating where a tradition should be accepted, refined or abandoned may be several. Some may see a tradition to be dysfunctional and hampers the progress of a society, “others may see it as discordant with the ethos of a new set of cultural values that a new generation is bent on establishing”7others may see it as morally unacceptable to the society.
In my view, neither the revivalists nor the anti-revivalist are entirely correct in their argument and criticism. They are both mistaken and unjustifiable views. The anti-revivalist (I am referring to the extreme group) position implies that though culture is the embodiment of people’s way of life nothing useful can be derived from the ideas, values and practices of their culture. They see no reason why the past must be revived. Gospel and culture are for them ‘polar’ concepts that cannot be integrated.8 In my view, to argue that a great part of people’s culture be rejected is unacceptable. In fact a total rejection of one’s cultural past would be absurd. The revival of some cultural values is very legitimate and relevant, and this is what this study is seeking to do. But not every aspect of a cultural heritage ought to be revived. Thus it will be impossible for me to support the position of the revivalist, if that position were to advocate the revival of the whole corpus of the culture. For the revivalist also argues that for development to take place the whole culture must be revived. I disagree with this position, because some cultural elements hinder progress. The revivalist who does not show any awareness of the negative features of the culture that impede progress, is misguided and his view will be counterproductive.
My position is neither cultural revivalism nor cultural anti-revivalism but appropriating the positive elements in African culture. By appropriation I mean, critically examining ideas and values embedded in African culture and giving them a theological meaning. Some of the values would have to be retrieved, refined, improved, and re-evaluated. There are values that can be regarded as so fundamental to the existence of the African culture that they transcend every generation. Appropriating these elements and giving them theological meaning will suggest that something worthwhile can be developed from the African cultural past.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


